In her striking debut novel, Nowhere, Allison Gunn guides readers down a rabbit hole of grief, guilt, and supernatural horror set against the isolated backdrop of small-town Appalachia. Nowhere is a masterful blend of family drama and cosmic terror that subverts expectations at every turn, offering a fresh perspective on familiar horror tropes while diving deep into the emotional complexities of its characters.
What begins as a small-town missing person investigation spirals into an exploration of personal demons, generational trauma, and the thin veil between our world and the supernatural. Gunn’s literary prowess shines as she weaves together elements of cosmic horror, Appalachian folklore, and intimate family dynamics into a narrative that is as emotionally devastating as it is terrifying.
The Heart of Darkness: Plot and Pacing
Nowhere by Allison Gunn follows the fractured Kennan family in the small town of Dahlmouth, Virginia. Police Chief Rachel Kennan is struggling to hold herself together after the death of her young son Aidan in a car accident caused by her husband Finn’s drunk driving. Their marriage is in tatters, held together only by their two surviving daughters, thirteen-year-old Charlie and six-year-old Lucy.
When a mutilated body is discovered in the woods, followed by the disappearance of multiple children, including Charlie, Rachel must confront not only the town’s growing hostility toward her family but also supernatural forces that seem to be targeting the town’s youth. As the investigation unfolds, the boundaries between reality and nightmare blur, forcing Rachel and Finn to reckon with their past mistakes while fighting to save what remains of their family.
The pacing is masterful, with Gunn carefully balancing moments of intense horror with quieter, character-driven scenes that allow readers to catch their breath before plunging them back into the nightmare. The story builds to a crescendo that feels both inevitable and shocking, a rare achievement in horror fiction.
Broken People in a Broken Town: Character Development
The novel’s greatest strength lies in its complex, deeply flawed characters. Rachel and Finn are not heroes; they are broken people whose grief, guilt, and resentment have calcified into mutual hatred. Their dynamic feels painfully authentic, capturing the way tragedy can transform love into its bitter opposite.
Rachel is a particularly compelling protagonist – a closeted queer woman who sacrificed her identity to build a family, only to lose it all. Her character arc is nuanced and heartbreaking, exploring how grief can manifest as anger and how easy it is to displace that anger onto those we once loved. Her conflicted relationship with her sexuality adds another layer of complexity to her character without reducing her to stereotypes.
Finn represents a different kind of brokenness – a once-promising writer consumed by alcoholism and self-loathing. His struggle to connect with his surviving daughters while drowning in guilt over Aidan’s death is depicted with unflinching honesty. Gunn doesn’t excuse his behavior, but she allows readers to empathize with his pain.
The daughters, Charlie and Lucy, are equally well-developed. Charlie’s adolescent rebellion takes on a sinister edge as the story progresses, while Lucy’s eerie drawings and cryptic warnings serve as a window into the supernatural elements lurking beneath the surface of Dahlmouth.
The Horror That Lurks in the Woods: Atmosphere and Setting
Gunn excels at creating atmosphere, transforming the fictional town of Dahlmouth into a character in its own right. The oppressive religious fundamentalism, suspicion of outsiders, and close-minded prejudice create a pressure cooker environment even before the supernatural elements come into play.
The woods surrounding Dahlmouth are described with a poet’s eye for detail, becoming increasingly threatening as the narrative progresses. Gunn understands that true horror lies not in what is shown but in what is suggested, and she uses this principle to great effect, allowing readers’ imaginations to fill in the most terrifying details.
Strengths That Shine Through the Darkness
Several elements of Nowhere by Allison Gunn stand out as particularly exceptional:
Unflinching exploration of grief – Gunn portrays the messy, complicated nature of loss without resorting to platitudes or easy answers. Each character processes their grief differently, and none of those processes are neat or linear.
LGBTQ+ representation – Rachel’s struggle with her sexuality is handled with nuance and authenticity. It informs her character without defining her, and adds meaningful complexity to her relationships.
Blending of cosmic horror with family drama – The supernatural elements serve as perfect metaphors for the characters’ internal struggles, creating a cohesive narrative where the personal and cosmic horrors mirror and amplify each other.
Atmospheric prose – Gunn’s writing is visceral and evocative, with descriptions that engage all five senses to create a fully immersive reading experience.
Shadows and Flaws: A Critical Lens
Despite its strengths, Nowhere is not without its imperfections:
Pacing issues in the middle section – The investigation occasionally gets bogged down in details that, while adding to the atmosphere, slow the narrative momentum.
Some secondary characters lack development – While the Kennan family is richly drawn, some townspeople feel more like types than individuals, occasionally verging on stereotypes of rural Appalachians.
Resolution leaves questions unanswered – The ending, while powerful, may frustrate readers looking for more concrete explanations of the supernatural phenomena. This ambiguity is likely intentional but may not satisfy all readers.
Uneven handling of religious themes – The critique of religious fundamentalism occasionally lacks the same nuance given to other aspects of the story.
Final Verdict: A Compelling Debut That Haunts Long After the Last Page
Nowhere announces Allison Gunn as a formidable new voice in literary horror. Her ability to balance supernatural dread with profound emotional stakes creates a reading experience that is as moving as it is terrifying. The novel’s exploration of parental guilt, small-town prejudice, and the monsters we create through our own actions resonates long after the final page.
For fans of Gillian Flynn’s Sharp Objects, Stephen King’s Pet Sematary, or the cosmic horror of Laird Barron, Nowhere by Allison Gunn offers a fresh perspective on familiar themes. Gunn’s debut stands apart through its emotional honesty and the way it uses supernatural elements to illuminate human truths rather than obscure them.
While not perfect, the novel’s flaws are the growing pains of a promising writer finding her voice, and they’re far outweighed by its strengths. Nowhere is a haunting exploration of what happens when the boundaries between worlds – both supernatural and emotional – begin to dissolve.
Who Should Venture into Nowhere?
This novel will particularly appeal to readers who enjoy:
Character-driven horror that prioritizes emotional depth over cheap scares
Stories that blend family drama with supernatural elements
Complex, flawed protagonists grappling with guilt and grief
Atmospheric writing with a strong sense of place
LGBTQ+ representation in genre fiction
Ambiguous endings that leave room for interpretation
However, potential readers should be aware that the novel contains graphic violence, child death, domestic abuse, homophobia, and substance abuse. These elements are handled thoughtfully and serve the story, but they may be triggering for some readers.
The Beginning of a Notable Career
As a debut novel, Nowhere suggests that Allison Gunn has a bright future ahead. Her understanding of character psychology, gift for atmosphere, and willingness to tackle difficult themes mark her as a writer to watch. While her background in history and library science informs the rich detail of her fictional world, it’s her insight into human nature that makes Nowhere truly memorable.
For those willing to venture into the darkness alongside the Kennan family, Nowhere offers a rewarding journey through grief, guilt, and the possibility of redemption – even when that redemption comes at a terrible price. This isn’t a novel that offers easy answers or comforting conclusions, but its honesty and emotional complexity make it a standout debut in contemporary horror fiction.
Nowhere leaves its readers with an unsettling question: What darkness might be waiting for us in the woods of our own making? The answer, Gunn suggests, may be more terrifying than any supernatural entity – and far more difficult to escape.