Categories
Book Reviews

This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars

Thirteen heirs stand around a marble table in a palace armory, each holding a dull ball of metal. They have two minutes to turn it into its truest form. One heir dissolves his into glittering light, another flattens hers into a mirror, and Revel, sent here under a name that is not hers, tries for silver and ends up with a lump blotched with copper. The answer, it turns out, was to purify the lead and leave it as lead. This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars keeps circling back to that small humiliation, because its heroine’s whole problem is that she cannot accept anything, least of all herself, as it actually is.

A Prisoner in Borrowed Silver

Revel has reasons to be hard on herself. She was the only wielder born to House Erevos in generations, a poor rice-growing House where her father pushed her through late-night experiments and prized her for what her power could do. One catastrophic day in her childhood, which the novel returns to in flashbacks and nightmares, left her family broken and her mother unable to look at her. Years later she avenged her brother by killing the heir of House Bellatoris, and the price was her freedom, her House, and her mother and sister held hostage.

So when Bellatoris sends her to the Call, a brutal contest among the heirs of every House for a newly surfaced god shard, she goes as a weapon. Her secret orders are to take the shard and kill Axus Tassian, the Warbringer, the Prime’s adopted heir and the most feared alchemist alive. Their first meeting ends with her nicking her own finger on her dagger in a corridor. Their second involves her stabbing him properly, and watching the wound close.

This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars builds its romance out of that impossible premise, and the best of it is unhurried. A night sheltering from wolf-like beasts in a ruined arch, dried meat seasoned with berries he picked at a cliff edge, a conversation about the cruelty of being called an outsider: these are the moments where Axus becomes a person and Revel’s resolve starts to slip. Heat stays at a simmer for most of the book, with one explicit scene late on and no full consummation.

What This Wretched Alchemy Learns From Its Monsters

The setting is a fusion that should not work and mostly does. Ryumere’s Houses run on the vocabulary of imperial Rome, all Primes, legates and triumphal arches, while the Stills beyond the palace walls are haunted by creatures out of Japanese folklore. The most memorable is a faceless shapeshifter that walks out of the dusk wearing a wounded teammate’s face, walking a little too easily and smiling a little too symmetrically. Revel spots the wrongness in the skin before anyone else does, and the fight that follows on the lip of a chasm is genuinely frightening.

What gives the wasteland its heart, though, is the makeshift team that forms to cross it. Chlo, a thirteen-year-old archer who wears a brass hairpin shaped like a fork-tailed monster cat, is the first to join what Revel jokingly calls the Ruiners, a name born from a word of comfort her grandmother taught her. Hellast, a giant who once lost a daughter to an illness the Prime’s trade laws left untreated, becomes her protector without saying so. This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars is far warmer in these campfire scenes than its grim reputation suggests, and readers who get attached should brace themselves.

Poems in the Margins

Revel composes verse in her head when things hurt too much to say plainly, fragments set into the text in italics, and a few chapters open with lines credited to her. It is a lovely device, and Mars extends it into the romance: Axus turns out to know the work of the doomed poet-lovers Telisus and Emeril by heart, and the two of them trade lines across a ballroom like blades. The motif gives the love story a texture beyond banter, and it is the one element of This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars that feels entirely its own rather than borrowed from the genre’s shelf. Revel guards her verses fiercely, sharing them with nobody but her tattoo, so the moments when someone else recognises a line she loves land with real weight. The old Hermetic idea of as above, so below, which Revel repeats like a prayer, gets a similar double life, as a rule of magic and a statement about the self.

Where This Wretched Alchemy Overreaches

The ambition of This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars is real, but so are the problems, and they are not small:

The prose returns to the same reactions so often (bobbing throats, hitched breaths, darkening grey eyes) that they stop registering, and the profanity, real and invented, never lets up.
A long chapter of interior reckoning near the end spells out in plain therapeutic language what the rest of the book had already shown.
The final chapters deliver one reversal after another, undoing a death almost at once and reframing the central relationship in a way that will trouble some readers.
The Call itself, set up with teams and leaders and a deadline, quietly stops mattering as a contest.

Few of these faults are fatal on their own; together they make the final third feel rushed where the opening two thirds had room to breathe. Readers should also know the book contains violence and gore, the death of a child, grief, suicidal thoughts, captivity and coercion, and self-harm within its magic.

The Writer Behind the Wretched Alchemy

Tina Mars, a debut novelist from Southern California, says in her author’s note that the world grew from her father’s stories of growing up in Japan and her lifelong fascination with ancient Rome. Her interest in alchemy predates the book: she worked as a research lab assistant in college, squeezed between organic chemistry classes, and has spoken of the old tradition as the meeting point of science and mysticism. A decade of tabletop role-playing supplied the heroine; her first character was a hot-headed cleric, and Revel inherited the temper. She has also kept a journal since early childhood, poems included, which explains a good deal about the verse threaded through this novel. This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars opens the Ruinous Fate Saga, and its ending leaves almost every relationship in pieces. Saturday Books, an imprint of St. Martin’s, published it on 10 November 2026.

After the Last Page

Readers who came to Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros for its mix of lethal trials and banter will find a darker, more folkloric cousin here. The Poppy War by R. F. Kuang offers a heavier take on war, power and East Asian myth, while The Hunger Games remains the touchstone for a hostage forced to fight in someone else’s spectacle. This Wretched Alchemy by Tina Mars is uneven and too fond of its own reversals, but at its best it is a novel about learning to value what one already is, and it ends on a cliff steep enough to guarantee readers will be waiting for the sequel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *