A novel about how competition can make champions, but it can also expose the parts of us we work hardest to hide
In The Players We Were, Janelle Gabay delivers a contemporary young adult sports drama that dives far deeper than tennis rankings and tournament wins.
Though rooted in the high-stakes world of junior tennis, the novel wrestles with addiction, secrecy, family fracture, ambition, and the fragile intensity of female friendship. Gabay’s novel poses an urgent question: When winning becomes everything, what does it cost the people standing across the net from us and beside us?
“Girls who have boyfriends lose interest in tennis, drop in ranking, become emotionally unstable—too jealous, too angry, too happy—and then the losses pile up.”
The novel centers on two elite junior tennis players, Alex and Madison, whose partnership evolves into rivalry, betrayal, and something far more complicated. As their competitive paths intertwine, misunderstandings and hidden intentions escalate into consequences that reach well beyond the court. Alex is driven by her dream of collegiate tennis and the security it promises her family, but she is haunted by guilt and the fear that she is never quite good enough.
Meanwhile, Madison longs for stability, whether that be at home, in her friendships,, or within herself, and she fights to rebuild her life after destructive decisions threaten everything she values. As pressure mounts from tournaments, parents, and peers, both girls must confront who they are when the match is no longer just about tennis.
“Madison’s reputation continues to haunt her, and I’m sick of it haunting me too.”
The novel alternates between Alex and Madison’s perspectives in a way that mirrors the rhythm of a rally. Alex’s chapters unfold in first person, immersing readers directly in her anxiety, ambition, and spiraling guilt. Madison’s chapters are written in third person, offering a slight emotional distance that reflects her own struggle to understand herself. This back-and-forth narration feels emblematic of a tennis ball crossing the net with its action, reaction, and return. Each chapter opens with a tennis term that subtly parallels the emotional stakes, reinforcing how the sport serves as both literal setting and extended metaphor. The alternating viewpoints create dramatic tension, as readers often see misinterpretations forming before the characters do.
“All the greats put tennis first, above parties and popularity, and now they’re successful and famous and living a lavish life. That’s what I want.”
Gabay’s narrative captures the psychological intensity of both competitive sports culture and being a young woman on the brink of adulthood. The pressure to perform, the fear of losing scholarships, and the fragile line between confidence and self-doubt feel authentic.
The novel also excels in portraying the messy realism of teenage relationships, especially female friendships that oscillate between loyalty and jealousy. Madison and Alex are not flattened into heroes or villains, but rather, we see them as flawed, reactive young women who are desperately trying to do their best but struggle with the necessary failure that comes with maturing. Gabay also thoughtfully portrays addiction recovery and accountability, showing that growth rarely happens in neat, linear arcs.
“I wish I was a raindrop.”
At times, the present-tense narration and short, clipped sentences can make the prose feel choppy. The pacing rarely pauses for reflection, which may leave some readers wanting deeper interior development in certain scenes. However, this stylistic choice also mirrors the physical and emotional exhaustion of tennis itself. The immediacy places readers directly inside the match, pushing us to physically feel breathless, tense, and reactive like the characters. What can feel abrupt also reinforces the story’s urgency. The intensity mirrors the heightened emotional reality of adolescence, where everything feels immediate and irreversible.
“When you step on that court, you’d better be tough as nails because this game will beat you down, turn friends into enemies, and enemies into family.”
The Players We Were is a story about choosing honesty over pride and solidarity over rivalry. It will resonate most with teen readers, athletes, and anyone who has navigated competitive environments where ambition and personal relationships are at odds. The novel contains sensitive themes including substance abuse, self-harm, and mental health struggles, so readers should approach with awareness. Yet beneath those heavier elements lies a hopeful message that success is not diminished when shared, and sometimes the most important victory is learning how to stand beside someone instead of against them.
The post The Players We Were by Janelle Gabay appeared first on Independent Book Review.