A character-rich small town mystery about how we can’t change the past without deadly consequences
Who decides when a story has ended? Who decides which stories get told? And how long can a story stay buried, before it comes back to haunt those who would rather forget? Game warden and part-time constable Nate Briggs faces these questions and more in this mystery as tangled as the roots of Vermont’s family trees.
When a freak storm unearths a local cemetery, all hands are on deck to make sense of the long-buried history and to return the town’s dead to their resting places. That is, until the only casket left intact is revealed to hold not only a century-old corpse, but also the body of an unidentified toddler, dead only a few months.
And when the initial spark of a motive is presented—coming with its own eerie set of questions—the only thing clear to the constable is that sometimes, the stories we tell ourselves and each other can have deadly, devastating consequences.
In this compelling small town mystery, the investigation and character work develop alongside one another. Nate’s “no profiling” mantra initially reads as a straightforward professional principle, but this case gradually exposes how difficult it is to apply the principle consistently. But in the end, instinct is no substitute for evidence, and Nate must put his loyalty to some and his friction with others to the side.
This parallel plot- and character-development is well supported by the measured pacing of this mystery. Short chapters and a steady accumulation of questions keep the investigation moving, while each new piece of information has the potential to change the shape of what came before. Both enjoyable and thematically poignant, much of the investigation is grounded in archival work and the stories we tell—to ourselves and to each other. The result is a satisfying novel that circles the central question of responsibility right until the last moment.
But as the historical pieces begin to fall into place, the investigation opens up an equally intriguing avenue that receives less attention: the people behind the motive. Perhaps antithetical to the “no profiling” mantra, readers may miss a deeper interrogation of how the various suspects fit the profile Briggs is building from the evidence and how their emerging motivation might manifest differently.
One element that may divide readers is the shift in tone as the novel progresses. The gruff, understated voice established early on—consistent with the characterization of the constable—tends to lean more literary. While the addition of more nuanced and poetic observations brings additional dimensions to the character of Nate Briggs, these sensibilities at times feel somewhat forced upon his initial archetype. For readers who enjoy their mysteries with a stronger emphasis on character and interiority, this will prove a welcome addition; for those drawn primarily to the investigation itself, some of these quieter detours may feel less integral to the case.
The Weight of the Dead thrives as its mystery and themes intermingle, with history becoming both the setting and the method by which the truth is uncovered. This thoughtful story understands that we rarely possess the whole truth about another person, only the fragments they leave behind, and that an incomplete or unfamiliar story is not necessarily untrue.
The post The Weight of the Dead by S.A. Morris appeared first on Independent Book Review.